Skip to main content

Portola Customers Press Liberty Utilities on Rising Bills

Business owners say high costs and outages threaten their survival.

5 min read

PORTOLA — The parking lot at the Portola Veterans Hall was crowded Thursday night as local residents arrived for a public meeting with representatives of the city’s electricity provider, Liberty Utilities. The meeting had been requested by Portola officials following discussions of the rising cost of electric service at a city council meeting on October 14, but was organized and presented by the utility company.

Thursday’s meeting was billed as an open session where Liberty customers could ask questions about electric service and rates. Sheriff Chad Hermann, who lives in Portola, opened the meeting with a request that anticipated the tone of the meeting: he acknowledged that the discussion could be “contentious” and asked participants to be respectful of each other.

The president of Liberty’s local subsidiary, Eric Schwarzrock, signaled similar expectations in his initial remarks: “I know we’re going to take some on the chin tonight,” he said after introducing himself. He pointed out tables around the room where attendees could go for information about bills, operations, and assistance programs, then started a slide presentation he said would take about 15 minutes. Questions and comments from the audience began with the first few slides.

Schwarzrock explained that all of Portola’s power flows through a 60 kilovolt transmission line from Truckee to a substation that Liberty renovated in 2024. Eighty percent of Liberty’s power supply is purchased from NV Energy, he said, but NV Energy is terminating that arrangement next year. “Because of data centers,” someone in the audience said. It has been reported that NV Energy’s decision was driven by unprecedented demand, including from data centers in Nevada. Schwarzrock continued that his company is reviewing bids from 14 other companies interested in selling power to Liberty. “The last thing I want is to be the person with the highest rates,” he said. “You are; why don’t you sell to Plumas Sierra?” others in the audience said, to applause. Plumas Sierra Rural Electric Co-op (PSREC) is the electric utility for adjoining unincorporated areas, including Sierra Valley and Graeagle. Other speakers throughout the meeting advocated for Liberty to sell its local assets to PSREC.

Kate Rahmeyer, Executive Director of Plumas Crisis Intervention and Resource Center, a local non-profit that provides safety-net services, offered to provide “hard data” on the increasing cost of electric service. She said her organization helped 20 clients pay bills from Liberty totaling $16,600 in 2024, 12 clients with bills of $16,500 in 2025, and 15 clients with bills totaling $39,000 through September 2026. Those amounts represent an increase in the average cost per person from $831 in 2024 to $2627 in 2026, she said. The clients her organization serves are “seniors, disabled folks and low-income folks” on fixed incomes “and they will not survive,” she said.

Another speaker, who did not identify himself, also addressed the rising cost of power. “Here’s the main fact that matters: it’s about the rate you charge us,” he said. The rate he currently pays in Portola is 46 cents per kilowatt-hour (kWh), compared to 21 cents per kWh for PSREC and 14 cents per kWh for NV Energy in Reno, he said, and his rate has increased steadily from 21 cents per kWh in 2022. “That is robbery compared to what we could get locally,” he said. He pointed out that Portola residents are being urged to switch from wood to electric heat, “but we don’t get the reliability, plus we get the increased cost that’s killing people,” he said. “Please tell me how you justify this cost,” he asked Schwarzrock.

Schwarzrock began to respond that the cost of wildfire mitigation work and wildfire liability insurance are the main reasons for Liberty’s increasing costs, but he was interrupted repeatedly by members of the audience. “Everybody has those costs,” someone said, while others asked, “What makes Liberty have to charge us 46 cents a kWh? That’s astronomical.” “Because they’re investor-owned; they have to make a profit off us,” another member of the audience responded. Schwarzrock then called on other speakers.

Members of the local business community also voiced concerns about electricity costs and reliability. A woman who identified herself as the owner of a restaurant said her electric bills were $1700 in July and $3200 in August; “that’s going to put me out of business,” she said. Her business has also been impacted by power outages; she said an outage in 2023 forced her business to shut down and resulted in the loss of food worth thousands of dollars. She added that the high cost of electricity threatens the survival of local businesses, whose loss could “potentially put this town into a crisis.”

Marcie Wilde, General Manager of the Feather River Food Cooperative, said their Portola store’s electric rates increased by 12% from 2024 to 2025 and another 14% from 2025 to 2026, bringing their monthly electric bill to $3,439 on average and more than $4900—about $160 a day—in September. The electric bill for the store is now more than twice the rent for the building, she said. “At some point, these increases become more than an operating expense; they become a threat to the long-term sustainability of local businesses,” she said. Her grocery store also lost $18,000 during a power outage and then faced an increase in its insurance premium, she added. “How are small businesses supposed to continue operating when the cost of electricity keeps increasing at this rate…it’s a question about the economic future of this community,” she said.

The meeting continued with Schwarzrock trying to explain Liberty’s insurance costs and wildfire mitigation work amid further comments and questions from the audience, but people started to drift away after about an hour. One man said, as he put on his coat to leave, “Who’s the next person to talk to? I took off work to be here, but I feel like we’re getting the run-around.” A small group stayed outside to meet with Danielle Hughes, a member of the California Energy Commission and founder of the Tahoe Spark advocacy group. Staff from the offices of state Senator Megan Dahle and Assemblywoman Heather Hadwick also attended the meeting, but did not address the audience.