Semi Driver Hits Parked Cars, Then Crashes Into Downieville Home
Suzanne Smith was reporting damage to her car when the truck came back down Durgan Flat Way.
6 min read
The trailer came to rest against Suzanne Smith and Kaifus Knoefler’s home at the corner of Durgan Flat Way.
Staff Photo
DOWNIEVILLE – A tractor-trailer struck a car and a fence as it turned onto Durgan Flat Way early Friday, November 20, then hit more vehicles on its way back out. The driver made it as far as the turn onto Durgan Bridge, where his trailer crashed through Suzanne Smith and Kaifus Knoefler’s back porch and wedged against their house.
The rig blocked the bridge to vehicles for nearly seven hours. County offices at the Sierra County Courthouse closed because the public could no longer reach them. The California Highway Patrol logged the crash at 5:38 AM. Three minutes later, firefighters at the scene reported no injuries.
A California Highway Patrol vehicle faces the semi on Durgan Bridge. The truck blocked vehicle access to the courthouse.
Staff Photo
The driver, William Altizer of North Carolina, had taken Highway 49 over Yuba Pass overnight to get around a snow closure on Interstate 80. He told California Highway Patrol Officer Jason Bice that his GPS directed him off the highway in Downieville and across Durgan Bridge toward the courthouse. Bice said Altizer hit the car and part of the fence as he turned onto Durgan Flat Way.
“I woke up to a crazy ruckus, thinking it was the snowplow,” Smith told The Mountain Messenger. From her dormer window she could see the back of the truck heading toward the Forest Service station. It took her a moment to realize her car had moved. She called the Sheriff’s Office to report that she thought the truck had hit it. When she went downstairs to look, she found her gate torn off.
Altizer continued to the parking lot at the end of the road, turned the rig around, and hit more vehicles on his way back toward the bridge. At least five vehicles were damaged, including Smith’s Honda, which had its roof crushed.
Damage to vehicles along Durgan Flat Way after the tractor-trailer’s two passes.
Staff Photo
Smith was still telling the dispatcher what she had found when she saw the truck again, this time at the stop sign outside her house. “I waved him down, and he kept going,” she said. Smith said the rig hit her back porch twice. The second time, she was running back inside as Altizer turned toward the bridge.
Smith headed downstairs to get Knoefler. He had felt the house shake and was already running upstairs to get her. Knoefler said he had thought the sounds outside were rocks hitting the house, or snowballs thrown up by a plow. When he looked out the door and saw the trailer against the house, he was afraid the whole house might fall. The trailer had pinched to a stop, he said, and he thought a large stone alongside it was keeping it from tipping farther into the house.
Recovery crews help return a large stone which had been displaced by the truck.
Staff Photo
Bice said Altizer should have stopped at the first collision, even if the rig was blocking the road. If Altizer had managed to straighten it out, “he probably would not have stayed here,” Bice said, adding that he couldn’t say for sure.
Asked why he kept driving, Altizer said he had his flashers on and wanted to get the rig straightened out before stopping to speak to Smith. He acknowledged he should have stopped sooner and said he would face the consequences. “I was gonna stop, you know, no matter what,” he said.
Bice said he would document what the truck hit and submit his report to the Sierra County district attorney, who would decide whether to file hit-and-run charges. Bice attributed the crash to an unsafe turn. After a brief field sobriety check, Bice said he saw no indication of impairment and had no plans to arrest Altizer at the scene.
CHP put Altizer out of service for violations involving the driving hours he recorded in his logbook. Bice said he expected the order to keep Altizer off the road for 12 hours. By Friday afternoon, Altizer was waiting out the order at the Downieville gas station.
Altizer said he was hauling close to 35,000 pounds of paper on pallets. Around 5 AM, he said, he was driving through snow and sleet, and he missed the signs warning about truck length. “Don’t follow your GPS,” he said.
Bice said truckers often try Highway 49 when Interstate 80 closes or backs up. Navigation apps pick up the delay and reroute drivers, he said. As for the turn onto the courthouse bridge, Bice thought Altizer might have misread the map or lost an update when phone service went out.
William Altizer stands beside his truck at Durgan Bridge after Friday’s crash.
Staff Photo
Caltrans marks Highway 49 through Downieville as a 65-foot route. Chris Murtey of Triple M Towing estimated Altizer’s tractor and trailer together were about 75 feet long. Bice said the rig was too long for the highway and that commercial drivers are responsible for knowing which routes they can use.
Freeing the trailer
The blocked bridge also delayed AT&T crews responding to a phone outage. The Sierra County Sheriff’s Office said AT&T had found a damaged section of fiber-optic line in the Galloway area south of Downieville. The damage appeared unrelated to the crash, the office said, but repair crews had to approach from the Pike and Alleghany area. Sierra County dispatchers used Starlink to stay in operation while Nevada County took 911 calls and relayed them back to Sierra County.
Triple M took the towing call. Murtey said his big tow truck could not get into the corner where the trailer was wedged, so he called an All American Towing operator out of Auburn. About 30 people gathered to watch the two operators work the trailer free with the smaller trucks. Triple M also brought up a tractor to haul the trailer back to Grass Valley.
The tow crew rigs cables to the trailer beside the house. Triple M Towing called in All American Towing because of the tight quarters.
Staff Photo
The crews freed the trailer from the house at about 12:30 PM. At 12:40 PM, the Sheriff’s Office confirmed that vehicles could cross Durgan Bridge again.
The trailer on Durgan Bridge after crews freed it from the house. The Sheriff’s Office confirmed the crossing had reopened at 12:40 PM.
Staff Photo
Who pays for the tow and repairs?
Altizer was hauling the paper for Reload Transport Inc. of Mokena, Illinois. Its insurance filing names National Specialty Insurance Company as its primary insurer for bodily injury and property damage.
The owners of the house, fence, and damaged vehicles can file claims with the trucking company’s insurer. The insurer investigates who was responsible and how much the repairs will cost. If the trucking company is liable, its commercial auto insurance pays for covered damage up to the policy limit.
Owners can also turn to their own insurers. The California Department of Insurance says homeowners insurance typically covers damage when a vehicle hits a house. A vehicle owner with collision coverage can file a claim with their own insurer.
The tow bill is a separate expense. Murtey said the trailer was company-owned and Triple M would hold it in storage until the bill was paid. That arrangement would let Triple M collect without asking Altizer to pay the full bill out of pocket at the roadside. Altizer told Murtey he expected his insurance to cover the tow.